James Street Mennonite Church 323 West James Street Get Directions Phone 717-396-6707 Website View Website Hours The James Street Mennonite Church is an Anabaptist congregation gathering in Lancaster City that is empowered by the Holy Spirit to follow Jesus’ command to love God and neighbor as self. Their envision being that of a gracious Christian community in a world that is increasingly polarized, offering a safe context where people are welcome to embrace their uniqueness and express their differences in an atmosphere of belonging.